ExpressVPN vs. SurfShark

ExpressVPN: expressvpn.com

SurfShark: surfshark.com

Security and Privacy

ExpressVPN

Pros: Top-tier security features with AES-256 encryption and TrustedServer technology, which ensures all servers run on RAM and data is wiped with every reboot. No-logs policy backed by independent audits.
Cons: The British Virgin Islands jurisdiction is generally good for privacy, but some users might still be cautious about any potential influence from UK laws.

Surfshark

Pros: Uses strong AES-256 encryption and offers MultiHop (double VPN) and CleanWeb (ad/malware blocking) features. Also, has a strict no-logs policy and operates under the privacy-friendly jurisdiction of the British Virgin Islands.
Cons: Surfshark is relatively new compared to ExpressVPN, so while it hasn’t had major security incidents, it doesn’t have the same long track record of reliability.

Performance and Speed

ExpressVPN

Pros: Known for consistently fast speeds, especially with its Lightway protocol. Ideal for streaming, gaming, and downloading large files.
Cons: The high cost might feel like you’re overpaying, especially when considering that some cheaper options provide comparable speeds.

Surfshark

Pros: Generally fast speeds and reliable performance. Good for streaming and torrenting with decent consistency.
Cons: Occasionally, speeds can drop, particularly on some servers. Not as consistently fast as ExpressVPN, but generally sufficient for most users.

User Interface and Experience

ExpressVPN

Pros: Clean, intuitive interface that’s easy to use. One-click connection and straightforward server switching.
Cons: The simplicity might be too basic for power users who want more control over their settings.

Surfshark

Pros: User-friendly with a clean and straightforward interface. Available on a wide range of platforms, and offers features like a built-in kill switch and split tunneling.
Cons: While user-friendly, the app can occasionally be buggy. Some advanced features are buried deep in the menus, making them hard to find for less tech-savvy users.

Streaming and Torrenting

ExpressVPN

Pros: Excellent for streaming with reliable access to services like Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and Amazon Prime. Rarely gets blocked, and if it does, customer support helps quickly.
Cons: Higher cost can be a downside if your primary need is streaming and there are cheaper options available that work nearly as well.

Surfshark

Pros: Works well with most major streaming services. Unlimited simultaneous connections are a huge plus for families or households with many devices.
Cons: Sometimes requires server switching to find one that works with certain streaming platforms, which can be inconvenient.

Pricing and Plans

ExpressVPN

Pros: Often runs promotions, like additional free months with annual plans. Offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Cons: Higher cost compared to many competitors. It’s one of the most expensive options on the market, which can be off-putting.

Surfshark

Pros: Very affordable, especially with long-term plans. Offers excellent value for money with features that rival more expensive services. Also has a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Cons: The low price might make some users skeptical about its quality and reliability, though it generally holds up well.

Device Compatibility and Simultaneous Connections

ExpressVPN

Pros: Extensive device compatibility, including niche devices and smart home tech. Allows up to 5 simultaneous connections.
Cons: Fewer simultaneous connections than Surfshark, which can be limiting for larger households.

Surfshark

Pros: Unlimited simultaneous connections, which is a huge advantage. Broad device support, making it versatile for various use cases.
Cons: The unlimited connections might be overkill for single users or small households, but it’s great for families.

Additional Features

ExpressVPN

Pros: MediaStreamer DNS service is excellent for devices that don’t support VPNs. TrustedServer technology is a significant security enhancement.
Cons: Lacks some of the niche features that Surfshark offers, focusing instead on core functionality and reliability.

Surfshark

Pros: CleanWeb ad and malware blocker, MultiHop, Whitelister (split tunneling), and NoBorders mode for use in restrictive regions.
Cons: Some features, like MultiHop, can slow down your connection, and the interface for these features isn’t as polished as it could be.

Summary Recommendation

For Budget-Conscious Users or Larger Households: Surfshark is the better choice. It offers great value for money, unlimited device connections, and a solid set of features. Just be prepared for occasional bugs and slightly less polished performance.
For Those Seeking Top Performance and Reliability: ExpressVPN remains a top contender. You’re paying a premium, but you get consistent speeds, top-tier security, and excellent support. If budget is less of a concern, the reliability and performance make it worth it.

In the end, both are excellent VPN services, but your choice will depend on your specific needs. Surfshark is great if you need to connect many devices on a budget, while ExpressVPN is ideal if you prioritize performance, security, and seamless streaming.